Friday, May 13, 2005

It's almost funny
U.S. inmate Michael Ross on death row has waived all further appeals of his sentence and has been recently executed. Despite his having been found competent by the courts, attorney Polan and some others claim that his willingness to accept death indicates, in and of itself, that he was insane. Also, opponents of the death penalty predict that the execution will trigger a chain reaction in the area that will "break down" barriers against capital punishment. It's not clear to me how an inmate accepting his death sentence is going to encourage juries and courts to impose the death penalty on a more regular basis; supposedly those upright citizens are all sane and of sound morality, so if they find the sentence repugnant and only impose it as punishment for the most heinous of crimes, it's doubtful that the frequency of that sentence is going to increase unless, that is, more people commit such crimes. But it's incredulous to think that someone who is determined to die would choose this as a method; it's much less trouble to jump off a bridge or hang. And if someone was so twisted as to rape and kill other people with a view toward getting a free lethal injection for himself, perhaps the kindest thing a person could do for him and for society as a whole would be to grant his wish, preferably before he could do either of those things.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

"It's not clear to me how an inmate accepting his death sentence is going to encourage juries and courts to impose the death penalty on a more regular basis" ...

Perhaps inmates accepting their upcoming death without fighting it, means they move through the system quicker, saving lots of taxpayer's money. Storing people on death row seems to be a costly business, even costlier than life time imprisonment in a regular prison.

euclid said...

"Perhaps inmates accepting their upcoming death without fighting it, means they move through the system quicker, saving lots of taxpayer's money."

Perhaps. But then Ross had been on death row 18 years; if it takes the typical inmate on death row even half that time to get fed up with living, i'm not sure if the typical US taxpayer is going to notice the savings.